Who Is In Charge

A ‘told you so’ about breakaway school districts leaves out urban district left behind

PHOTO: Jim Weber / The Commercial Appeal
Students, teachers and parents gather for the Pledge of Allegiance outside Lakeland Middle Preparatory School during a dedication ceremony for the new school.

“About time for suburbs to chant ‘Told you so’ to doubters of municipal school districts,” reads a headline from The Commercial Appeal column “Outside the Loop.”

The column points to several success stories from the six districts that pulled out of Shelby County Schools in 2014, especially the new school buildings going up in the growing districts.

But the column’s focus on how the districts overcame opposition leaves out important context — and some readers took issue with measuring success in infrastructure without taking into account how the exodus affected the urban school district left behind.

“The Commercial Appeal measures success by the number of buildings built, not the real harm done to children across the community, so by that measure, suburban schools are a success,” Wendi C. Thomas, a longtime Memphis journalist, said in a Facebook post linking to the column.

The columnist, Clay Bailey, who is also a reporter covering Bartlett and other suburban areas, wrote:

And whether naysayers agree with the enabling legislation creating municipal districts or court rulings opening the way or agreements that secured the bulk of the campuses within the suburban boundaries, the districts are preparing to start their fourth school year after secession from Shelby County Schools.

And quite successfully, despite the resistance from outside forces.”

There were many questions and concerns following the pullout of those six districts. But those largely focused on how the “de-merger” would affect the large school district left behind — not whether or not the more wealthy suburbs could financially make it on their own.

The suburban districts believed they could in part because there is more tax revenue concentrated in the suburbs.

That’s been a flashpoint for years. In recent decades, as property values increased in the suburbs, legacy Shelby County Schools — the now-nonexistent suburban district that included the six municipalities — was sending more and more of its revenue to Memphis schools, irking suburban officials who sought a way to keep those dollars local.

Their solution was to create a new, special school district — which prompted city school leaders to give up their charter to merge with the suburban district, and then the six districts to secede in response.

And though Shelby County Schools is headed into a new era of relative financial stability, district leaders still say the six-district pullout is one of many factors that have chipped away at resources available to the schools left behind.

That’s the history. More recently, the six municipal school districts were recently cast into the national spotlight as the “most egregious example” of more wealthy mostly white suburban districts seceding from urban districts of poorer minority students in a national report in June.

Bailey’s column faced some tough criticism online.

“Of course a segregated district is thriving,” said activist and educator Tami Sawyer in a Facebook post linking to the article. “Don’t act like y’all won the academic bowl. You’re thriving because due to white privilege you removed yourself from the ‘urban’ district and yet still get windfall from being formerly connected. Not to mention, no one was naysayers in the vein of thinking it couldn’t be done. They were naysayers in saying this is racially motivated and wrong.”

The triumphant tone from the reporter who regularly covers municipalities for the local newspaper did not sit will with Mark Hansen, chairman of the Collierville school board.

The column also drew praise from members of a few Facebook groups dedicated to discussing suburban school issues.

PHOTO: Facebook

Bailey declined to comment.

Correction, Aug. 4, 2017: A previous version of this story said Clay Bailey is an editor overseeing suburban coverage. As of March, Bailey was no longer an editor. 


Aurora’s superintendent will get a contract extension

Aurora Public Schools Superintendent Rico Munn. (Photo by Andy Cross/The Denver Post)

The Aurora school board is offering superintendent Rico Munn a contract extension.

Marques Ivey, the school board president, made the announcement during Tuesday’s regular board meeting.

“The board of education believes we are headed in the right direction,” Ivey said. Munn can keep the district going in the right direction, he added.

The contract extension has not been approved yet. Munn said Tuesday night that it had been sent to his lawyer, but he had not had time to review it.

Munn took the leadership position in Aurora Public Schools in 2013. His current contract is set to expire at the end of June.

Munn indicated he intends to sign the new contract after he has time to review it. If he does so, district leaders expect the contract to be on the agenda of the board’s next meeting, April 3, for a first review, and then for a vote at the following meeting.

Details about the new offer, including the length of the extension or any salary increases, have not been made public.

Four of the seven members currently on the board were elected in November as part of a union-supported slate. Many voiced disapproval of some of the superintendent’s reform strategies such as his invitation to charter school network DSST to open in Aurora.

In their first major vote as a new board, the board also voted against the superintendent’s recommendation for the turnaround of an elementary school, signaling a disagreement with the district’s turnaround strategies.

But while several Aurora schools remain low performing, last year the district earned a high enough rating from the state to avoid a path toward state action.

cooling off

New York City charter leader Eva Moskowitz says Betsy DeVos is not ‘ready for prime time’

PHOTO: Chalkbeat
Success Academy CEO and founder Eva Moskowitz seemed to be cooling her support for U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos.

In New York City, Eva Moskowitz has been a lone voice of support for the controversial U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. But even Moskowitz appears to be cooling on the secretary following an embarrassing interview.

“I believe her heart is in the right place,” Moskowitz, founder and CEO of Success Academy, said of DeVos at an unrelated press conference. “But as the recent interviews indicate, I don’t believe she’s ready for primetime in terms of answering all of the complex questions that need to be answered on the topic of public education and choice.”

That is an apparent reference to DeVos’s roundly criticized appearance on 60 Minutes, which recently aired a 30-minute segment in which the secretary admits she hasn’t visited struggling schools in her tenure. Even advocates of school choice, DeVos’s signature issue, called her performance an “embarrassment,” and “Saturday Night Live” poked fun at her.  

Moskowitz’s comments are an about-face from when the education secretary was first appointed. While the rest of the New York City charter school community was mostly quiet after DeVos was tapped for the position, Moskowitz was the exception, tweeting that she was “thrilled.” She doubled-down on her support months later in an interview with Chalkbeat.

“I believe that education reform has to be a bipartisan issue,” she said.

During Monday’s press conference, which Success Academy officials called to push the city for more space for its growing network, Moskowitz also denied rumors, fueled by a tweet from AFT President Randi Weingarten, that Success officials had recently met with members of the Trump administration.

Shortly after the election, Moskowitz met with Trump amid speculation she was being considered for the education secretary position. This time around, she said it was “untrue” that any visits had taken place.

“You all know that a while back, I was asked to meet with the president-elect. I thought it was important to take his call,” she said. “I was troubled at the time by the Trump administration. I’m even more troubled now. And so, there has been no such meeting.”