New York

Oversight of Regents scoring has serious flaws, state audit finds

The New York State Education Department is failing to ensure that Regents tests are properly scored, according to an audit published today by the state comptroller's office. The exams are given to high school students, who have to pass five in different subject areas in order to receive a Regents diploma. Teachers normally administer and score the tests under the supervision of each school's principal, and the school district is responsible for reporting scores to the state. The audit focused on the review process the state uses to ensure the scoring is accurate and consistent. In these reviews, a group of teachers and NYSED officials re-score a random selection of exams and compare them to how the tests were originally scored to judge the accuracy. The review team then makes recommendations to the state and to schools about how to improve the scoring process. In the most recent review, completed in 2005, the scores awarded by schools were routinely higher than the scores given by the reviewers, and reviewers reported that school scorers frequently assigned full credit to student answers that were "vague, incomplete, inaccurate or insufficiently detailed." But auditors found little to suggest that the state followed up to improve the process, the report says. "For example, we found no evidence actions were taken to implement the Review team's recommendations to improve scoring training and enhance quality control during the scoring process. We also found no evidence actions were taken to bring about improvements at particular schools," the auditors write.