Anti-CRT, pro-parental rights candidates win seats on Hamilton County school boards

a hand selects candidates on voting machine
Interest in school board races increased in Hamilton County following the nationalization of school board elections under the banner of parents’ rights — a response to school policies related to COVID, as well as diversity, equity, and inclusion measures. (IPB file photo)

Candidates who campaigned on a platform of parental rights, opposition to critical race theory, and claims that schools are indoctrinating students in liberal ideologies won seats in multiple Hamilton County school board races, according to unofficial election results. 

School boards in Indiana are made up of non-partisan officials, but campaigns in Hamilton County featured national political talking points and endorsements from high-profile politicians.

The winning candidates in Hamilton Southeastern, Tiffany Pascoe (District 1), Juanita Albright (District 2), Dawn Lang (District 3), and Ben Orr (District 4), were supported by the Hamilton County chapter of Moms for Liberty, a powerful and controversial conservative group that rose to prominence by opposing mask mandates, critical race theory and social emotional learning. The group aims to install like-minded people in school board seats across the country.

Amber Huff Willis (At Large), William Anderson (District 2) and Rebecca Ogle (District 4) won seats on the Westfield Washington school board; they were also supported by Moms for Liberty Hamilton County.

The Carmel Clay board race proved less successful for conservative candidates; incumbent Jennifer Nelson-Williams (District 2) won with 46% of the vote. She defeated conservative candidate Adam Sharp, who campaigned as part of a Republican-backed slate with Jenny Brake and Greg Brown.

Kristin Kouka (District 1) — who campaigned with Jake Nichols (District 3) and Nelson-Williams — won a seat on the board in a tight race against Brake; she received just 117 more votes than Brake, according to unofficial election results.

Greg Brown (District 3) is the only member of his slate to win a seat on the Carmel Clay board. And he received just 90 more votes than Nichols.

Nelson-Williams, Kouka and Nichols campaign in support of diversity, equity and inclusion efforts at Carmel-Clay schools, while the Brake, Brown and Sharp campaign claimed radical liberal teachers were indoctrinating Carmel students.

In the at-large race for the Noblesville school board, incumbent Joe E. Forgey received a plurality of the vote — about 29%. Misti Ray — another candidate supported by multiple anti-CRT groups — received the second most votes.

More than 48% of eligible voters in Hamilton County cast ballots in the mid term election. The deadline for the county to certify election results in Nov. 21. Candidates have until noon Nov. 22 to file for a verified recount or contest petition of election results.

Become a Chalkbeat sponsor

Carmel Clay School Board 

District 1 

Sheldon Barnes 11.48%

Jenny Brake 39.15%

Stephanie Flittner 9.88%

Kristin Kouka - Winner 39.49%

District 2 

Lori Long 10.02%

Jennifer Nelson-Williams - Winner 46.25%

Adam Sharp 43.73%

Become a Chalkbeat sponsor

District 3 

Greg Brown - Winner 50.15%

Jake Nichols 49.85%  

Hamilton Heights School Board 

Jackson Township 

Julie Davis - Winner 100%

White River Township 

Benjamin Lehman - Winner 59.83%

Doug Ozolins 40.17%

At Large 

Become a Chalkbeat sponsor

Arnie Cooper - Winner 100%  

Hamilton Southeastern School Board 

District 1 

Brad Boyer 12.14%

Edward Gedeon 2.63%

Jackie Howell 32.78%

Tiffany Pascoe - Winner 52.45%

District 2 

Juanita Albright - Winner 58.76%

Janet Pritchett 41.24%

District 3 

Carla Cork 38.56%

Dawn Lang - Winner 61.44%

District 4 

Julie Chambers 41.61%

Harry Delks 2.66%

Ben Orr - Winner 55.73%  

Noblesville School Board 

At Large (top 2 candidates win) 

Joe Forgey - Winner 28.52%

Chuck Haberman II 21.19%

Melba Kiser 19.57%

Brian Laskey 8.04%

Misti Ray - Winner 22.68%  

Sheridan School Board 

Adams Township 

Tyler Henning 44.08%

Kim Zachery - Winner 55.92%

At Large 

Nancy Boone - Winner 47.57%

Drew Carlisle 20.11%

Cheri Hume 32.32%  

Westfield Washington School Board 

District 2 

William Anderson - Winner 51.19%

Patrick Phillips 48.81%

District 4 

Rebecca Ogle - Winner 56.08%

Jill Woerner 43.92%

At Large 

Patrick Fassnacht 27.52%

Alan Ford 12.06%

Amber Huff Willis - Winner 52.98%

Curtis Wyatt 7.43%

Contact WFYI education reporter Lee V. Gaines at Follow on Twitter: @LeeVGaines.

The Latest

A bill at the Indiana Statehouse that aims to hold back more students who fail the state’s reading exam, is advancing. Here’s what its impact could be.

School districts across the state have grappled with a shortage of teachers.

Not everything has been smooth, but staff and parents say the good outweighs the hard.

During Tuesday’s budget address, Murphy proposed more money for K-12 public schools, marking the largest investment to schools in the state’s history.

Principals are the leaders of their schools and staff. But in Chicago, multiple entities have power over principals — and soon, an elected school board and a principals union could impact how school leaders work.