Philly cut substitute teacher roles to save money. Now the district wants $11 million more for them.

A photograph of three Black men standing side by side smiling and helping serve school children lunch.
Superintendent Tony Watlington said earlier this year that cutting building substitutes would save the district $13 million. But now, the district is seeking $11 million for substitute staffing services. (Kriston Jae Bethel for Chalkbeat)

Did you know search engines like Google are changing the way you see news? Keep Chalkbeat’s valuable education coverage at the top of your feeds by clicking here and checking the box next to our name.

Less than a year ago, Philadelphia school officials said eliminating hundreds of substitute teacher positions would save millions.

Now they’re asking for millions more to cover substitute staffing costs.

Last March, Superintendent Tony Watlington and Chief Financial Officer Mike Herbstman said cutting more than 200 building substitute positions would save the district $13 million, and help the district close a $300 million budget hole.

But at Thursday’s school board meeting, the district is asking the board to approve a contract amendment that would award a substitute staffing company, ESS Northeast LLC, an additional $11 million “to maintain essential substitute staffing services in the absence of employees across all District schools.”

The contract request raises new questions about whether the district’s elimination of those positions is delivering the savings officials promised, and if the cuts have left schools struggling to cover teacher absences. Advocates previously warned that losing the stability building substitutes provided would disrupt classrooms and strain teachers.

According to district data provided to the board, for the past four school years, there have been more requests for substitutes than the district has been able to provide, although the district’s ability to fill those requests has improved.

Public school advocacy groups like Lift Every Voice Philly fought the district’s decision to cut the building substitute positions. Now, the group says the bill has come due.

“At this rate, eliminating building substitutes could cost more than if we had kept them,” Lift Every Voice Executive Director Shanée Garner said in a Thursday statement. “We warned that eliminating these positions would strain schools already struggling with staffing shortages.”

According to the contract up for a vote Thursday evening, the $11 million would cover “essential substitute services” from the start of this school year through November 2026, due to the “elimination of Building Substitute positions.”

The extra funding would bring the district’s contract for substitute staffing services with ESS to $169.5 million through June 2027.

Board members Cheryl Harper and Joyce Wilkerson noted in a question and answer document that the $11 million is “a huge amount you’re asking for.”

School district and board spokespeople did not respond to Chalkbeat’s requests for comment.

District data shows there can be nearly 1,000 substitute requests lodged in a month.

In November 2022-23 for example, 505 substitute positions were filled out of 924 requested, or nearly 55%. By November 2025-26, nearly three-quarters of the requested sub positions, or 700 out of 938 requested, were filled.

The district has not provided that data for the 2026-27 school year.

Carly Sitrin is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Philadelphia. Contact Carly at csitrin@chalkbeat.org.

The Latest

After eliminating more than 200 building substitute positions to save $13 million, Philadelphia school officials want the board to approve $11 million in new money for substitute staffing services.

Denise Wilson, a fifth grade teacher at Winchester Elementary, shares advice for starting a school food pantry and calls for more state funding.

Research shows that extra pay can help attract and retain educators in high-poverty schools. Yet states have been reluctant to embrace this approach.

The Colorado Department of Education released six pages of guidance for schools and districts Wednesday.

Not getting additional funds is especially problematic for Chicago Public Schools, because its school board approved a $10 billion budget that assumes an additional $150 million from the state.

Gov. Jared Polis’ dashboard combines numerous data points to provide a view of Colorado students’ career readiness, civic experiences, and personal well-being.