Mask mandates remain at most Tennessee schools, poll shows

Students create distance between each other using their arms as they line up to go outside in Mrs. Cecarelliís second grade class at Wesley Elementary School in Middletown, CT, October 5, 2020.
While most Tennessee parents send their children to school in mask, parents are divided on other COVID safety measures such as vaccine mandates for teachers, according to the Vanderbilt Child Health Poll. (Allison Shelley for American Education: Images of Teachers and Students in Action)

Most Tennessee parents are sending their children to school wearing masks, and despite state law essentially banning mask mandates in public schools, most parents report that their child’s school requires masks. The findings are part of the Vanderbilt Child Health Poll, an annual survey that seeks parents’ feedback on the well-being of Tennessee children. 

The poll, conducted in late fall 2021, sampled 1,026 parents and found that region, race, and ethnicity influenced many parents’ opinions about COVID  safety protocols, with Black parents and West Tennessee parents having a stronger preference for safety measures. 

“While leaders need to take these differences of opinion into account, the guiding principle in setting school policies should be the well-being of all children,” said Dr. Joe Zickafoose, a pediatrician at Monroe Carell Jr. Children’s Hospital at Vanderbilt and one of the poll’s leading researchers. 

“Regardless of where we live in Tennessee, it’s important for everyone to remember and recognize that every school has at least a few children with underlying conditions that put them at high risk of severe COVID-19, and we know that it takes multiple prevention efforts to keep them safe in school,” he added.

The Vanderbilt findings on Tennessee parents’ divided view about masking complement the Momentive and Axios poll from the beginning of the school year that sampled 38,251 people nationwide and found that 56% of Tennessee respondents supported mask mandates for all students and staff.  

The divided views that both polls capture may reflect the conflicting COVID policies that abound in Tennessee as the state’s Republican lawmakers enacted a law to restrict masks mandates while federal judges issued orders blocking it.

Researchers conducted the Vanderbilt poll as some of the legal challenges unfolded, but before the rise of the omicron variant that has caused a spike in pediatric COVID cases statewide. Some key findings in the Vanderbilt poll include:

  • 53% of Tennessee parents reported that their children’s schools have a mask mandate in place.
  • 67% of Tennessee parents send their children to school in masks.
  • 54% of Tennessee parents said that students are safer in school when teachers and staff wear masks.
  • 40% of Tennessee parents both agreed and disagreed that schools should require COVID vaccines for all school staff, while 20% were indifferent. 

To see more results, visit childpolicy.org/poll.

The Latest

Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels said the city will scrap plans to close the Community Action School after a mom’s comment at a public meeting that appeared to insult the intelligence of a Black student garnered national attention.

Ideas submitted so far include an indoor-outdoor sports complex, new locations for charter schools, and apartments for teachers.

The MSCS school board voted last week to shutter five schools by the end of this year. That leaves over 1,200 students to find a new place to go next fall, with the district extending its priority transfer deadline to accommodate last-minute changes.

The district wanted to use the operating millage to pay off capital and revolving fund debts ahead of schedule. The ruling will not allow it.

The survey is in: Parent coordinators told us what they want the city to know about their jobs.

Newark Public Schools is trying to address overcrowding but finding available land to do so is tricky. The district will hold a public hearing on its proposal in late March.