Hybrid or elected school board? Lightfoot proposal stirs debate in Springfield

Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot discusses teacher contract negotiations on Oct. 7, 2019. Behind her, from left, are Chicago school board President Miguel del Valle, schools chief Janice Jackson, Chief Education Officer LaTanya McDade, and Alderman Michael Scott Jr.
Mayor Lori Lightfoot, center, has found an ally in Springfield to propose a new school board bill. Sen. Kimberly Lightford is set to fill a hybrid school board, that will have some mayoral appointees, with support from the mayor. (Yana Kunichoff / Chalkbeat)

Mayor Lori Lightfoot found a carrier for her bill to create a partially-elected Chicago school board — a state senator who on Wednesday voted for a rival effort to mandate a fully elected board.

Sen. Kimberly Lightford said she will sponsor the mayor’s bill for a partly elected and partly appointed “hybrid” board. 

On Wednesday, Lightford criticized a bill in the legislature to create a 21-person fully elected board, then promptly voted for the legislation.

She backed a bill by Sen. Robert Martwick, SB 2497, in the works for more than six years. It drew 1,102 comments in support and 242 opponents.

Even while criticizing Martwick’s bill, Lightford voted to send the bill out of committee and to the Senate floor, where there will be another opportunity for the bill to undergo more debate.

“I’ve never opposed the bill that Senator Martwick is carrying and in fact, I’ll vote for it today,” she said.

Lightford has not yet introduced the hybrid-board bill.

A supporter of the elected board, Jitu Brown, board president of the Kenwood-Oakland Community Organization on the city’s South Side, spoke about the decades-long fight to get an elected school board after the city closed scores of schools. 

“I have been a witness to literally dozens of mass mobilizations of parents frustrated because they did not have a voice. The inequity that was rooted in the struggling of their school was never addressed,” Brown said. 

He said that the city’s parents and community members organized behind an elected school board because there is not an instrument to hold the current appointed school board accountable to families. 

Sybil Madison, Chicago’s deputy mayor for education and human services, testified against the elected school board bill, citing progress that public schools have made since 1995, when the state gave the mayor control over the board. 

“In 2020, CPS had a record-high graduation rate at 83%. The University of Chicago research shows that CPS’ English language learners have equivalent gains and achievement from K through eighth grade as their peers who never classified as English language learners,” Madison said.

She mentioned that any version of the board should include parents’ voices because they have often felt left out of board decisions. 

After public testimony during the committee hearing, Lightford said that while she supported the idea of an elected school board, the Senate proposal for 21 members would be hard to implement. She raised concerns about the number of members, the cost of the board, finances for each race, and how to draw voting districts to ensure that all sides of the city are represented. 

“I would like to make sure that moving forward on something as significant as the impact of 350,000 students and their families that we do all we can to make sure that we have the best outcome as legislators and that we present a law that can be implemented,” said Lightford. 

Lightford has been instrumental in passing ambitious legislation. During the lame-duck session in fall, she pushed through a bill that created new graduation requirements for all Illinois students and more access to advanced courses. 

As news reports began to surface about the mayor’s counterproposal Wednesday morning, leaders of the city’s teachers union — which has helped push Martwick’s school board bill and contributed to legislators sponsoring Senate and House proposals — made it clear they would not sign on to a compromise plan that involved mayoral appointees. 

“We’re against a hybrid board. We want an elected school board,” said Union President Jesse Sharkey, speaking at a morning press conference about high school reopening and the union’s decision to call a work stoppage to protest the lack of a deal. 

“Our cards have been on the table for a long time. We think democracy works in every school district in the state. It should work here.”

The Latest

There’s already a blueprint for evaluation in the post-Regents era.

The policy says the superintendent should recommend schools identified for closure or consolidation by October, and the board should vote “no later than November.”

The new matrix comes more than a year after a shooting inside East High School and following state findings that DPS disproportionately suspends Black students with disabilities.

The district posted its opening proposals online and the union shared its contract ideas with members. Both sides want at least a four-year agreement.

“Our journey to get to this position in our lives was a rocky road to say the least.” This Philly student made it from home schooling to remote learning to class salutatorian.

Fewer high school students are vaping and drinking alcohol, but marijuana use has held steady.