Memphis-Shelby County Schools forensic audit set to begin in July

A group of people wearing suits walk in the background with a metal detector in the foreground an a mural on the wall on the right.
The contract for a forensic audit into Memphis-Shelby County Schools administration is set to begin in July. Tennessee lawmakers this spring earmarked $6 million for the deep dive into the district's finances and governance, and the state has requested immediate notification if the audit flags any apparent illegal activity. (Andrea Morales for Chalkbeat)

Sign up for Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free newsletter to keep up with statewide education policy and Memphis-Shelby County Schools.

Tennessee plans to launch a deep dive into Memphis-Shelby County Schools’ finances and administration in mid-July following Republican leaders’ insistence the district should be examined for irregularities amid discussions of a potential state takeover.

The contract for the state-funded forensic audit, which is designed to dig for potential fraud and abuse, is set to begin on July 17, according to documents published by the Tennessee Comptroller’s office. The office concluded a bidding process in early June and is expected to select a firm to perform the audit by the end of the month.

It’s not yet clear how long the audit could run, but the proposed contract would require the auditor to inform the state immediately if it discovers any evidence of fraud.

Rolling audit reports could keep the pressure on Memphis-Shelby County Schools even while lawmakers are in recess for the rest of the year.

Tennessee lawmakers this spring approved a $6 million budget item for the audit as Republican leaders called for a state takeover of the Memphis district.

The takeover legislation ultimately fell apart in the final days of the General Assembly session as Republicans couldn’t come to an agreement on the details of the plan.

But Republicans vowed to revive MSCS intervention legislation next year and say the results of the forensic audit could factor into the renewed effort.

“We’re going to really take a look at the books to see if there is fraud, abuse, or waste,” House Speaker Cameron Sexton, a Republican from Crossville, said earlier this year. “That has been mentioned to us time and time again that might be coming out of the school system.”

Per state law, the district already submits annual financial and compliance audits performed by an external firm, which have on occasion revealed things such as payroll lapses and contract overpayment.

The state audit funding was a significant increase over the $50,000 previously tapped by the Shelby County Commission for an audit earlier this year. The commission authorized the funds after it approved a no-confidence resolution directed at MSCS board members who opposed then-Superintendent Marie Feagins.

The state’s call for bids highlights that the audit should examine potential “fraud, waste, abuse, and any deficiencies” in the district, but it also calls for an evaluation on the “effectiveness and efficiency of MSCS operations” and its legal compliance.

A spokesperson from the Tennessee comptroller’s office declined to reveal which firms were in the running for the bid, or how many had expressed intent, citing a Tennessee law that shields sealed bids until the bidding process is complete.

Melissa Brown is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact Melissa at mbrown@chalkbeat.org.

The Latest

Pulaski was one of several schools in the Detroit school district that made the most progress in the state getting kids to school last year compared to 2018-19.

A letter sent by the school district’s acting general counsel called the U.S. Department of Education’s demands to roll back its Black Student Success Plan and overhaul policies related to transgender students “unreasonable and untenable.”

After a major charter school rally, 2 state senators are calling for an investigation into whether schools pressured families and staff to attend.

Memphis gym and health teachers will instruct students on gun safety curriculum this fall. Though some parents at a town hall this week asked to remove their kids from the training, a district official said that is not an option.

“If you want your kid to go to Harvard, make sure they have a responsive caregiver. Better than a tutor later on,” said Beth MeLampy, who directs curriculum and staff training at Gretchen’s House.

The eastside school district is considering moving fifth graders back into elementary schools as a way to balance enrollment and replicate popular programs.