What Indiana’s IREAD scores show about pandemic’s effects

Second grade teacher Mrs. Cecarelli, wearing a mask, holds up a placard with the words, “Which kid had the red dish” with the digraphs Wh, ch, th and sh underlined. A girl in a pink top stands in the foreground in a classroom, while a board with a projection of students participating remotely is in the background, at Wesley Elementary School in Middletown, CT, October 5, 2020.
A teacher holds up a question to her class. Results of the Indiana Reading Evaluation and Determination assessment show the unequal effects of the pandemic on Black and Hispanic students, (Allison Shelley for American Education: Images of Teachers and Students in Action)

Just over 80% of all Indiana third graders passed the 2021 spring reading assessment, according to state data released Friday. But achievement rates were far from equal across student groups.  

Results of the Indiana Reading Evaluation and Determination assessment show the unequal effects of the pandemic on Black and Hispanic students, as well as a widening gap between children who come from economically impoverished backgrounds and those who don’t. 

The gap in passing rates on state tests between white and Black students grew to 25.5 percentage points last spring from 2019. 

The data is in line with other information previously released by the state, like attendance rates which showed that students had unequal access to in-person learning during the 2020-21 school year.

ILEARN scores also showed that just over one quarter of students in grades 3 through 8 scored proficient in both English and math.

The state’s overall IREAD pass rate fell six percentage points from 87.3% in 2019 to 81.3%, but scores among Black third graders dropped by double that rate — the greatest decrease among student groups.

Around six in 10 of Black students passed the test, compared with 9 in 10 white students. 

The gap in passing rates between students who receive subsidized lunch and those who don’t also widened by five percentage points from 12.3% in 2019 to 17.4% last spring.

No demographic groups improved their scores from the spring tests from two years ago. 

That the pandemic hurt scores is not surprising, said Cristina Santamaría Graff, interim assistant dean of student support and diversity at Indiana University Purdue University in Indianapolis. 

The pandemic and efforts to control it caused schools to toggle between in-person and virtual learning; raised issues with access to resources, transportation, and communication devices; prompted many experienced teachers to leave; and posed severe challenges to students and families. 

Given that, putting a lot of weight on test scores is problematic, Santamaría Graff said. 

“Reading scores are one little lens to look at this massive issue of a lot of systems breaking down all at once,” she said. “And things that weren’t working before the pandemic are really falling apart.”

According to the state data, students in special education had the lowest IREAD pass rate in both 2019 and 2021, at 60.9% and 52.4%, respectively. 

But individual experiences with learning during the pandemic varied widely, said Santamaría Graff, an associate professor of special education and urban teacher education whose expertise includes bilingual and multicultural special education. 

Some families of students with autism reported that academics improved in a home environment, where they had more control over stimuli and sensory challenges. Meanwhile, students with Down Syndrome faced barriers to receiving consistent and quality virtual instruction, Santamaría Graff said, and saw corresponding declines in academic performance.

As a group, English learners seemed to have slipped the least from 2019 to 2021, by just 1.2 percentage points. 

Santamaría Graff noted that that data point required further investigation into, for example, what portion of English learners took state tests, whether they felt comfortable sitting for in-person assessments, and even whether immigrant families moved out of the state.

Looking to the new school year, Santamaría Graff said educators report feeling stretched thin, and may not have the bandwidth to provide students with all the support they need to catch up. 

But school districts and the state should involve families in decisions about how best to help students learn.

“It’s important to take a holistic view of the needs rather than pinpointing that students are doing poorly in reading and dedicating resources only to improving reading scores,” she said.  

The Latest

What is it like serving on a board of education? Here are 16 quotes from Chicago Public Schools’ 21-member partially-elected board that sum up the unpaid job.

Davis Aerospace students say the bikes have helped address some systemic barriers in getting to school.

Shenia Suggs has worked in the school district on the west side of Indianapolis for more than 30 years. She will take over as superintendent in January when outgoing Superintendent Jeff Butts leaves.

New York City high school applications are open. Here are tips from experts on how to narrow your search to build the best list for your child.

Mayor Lee Harris rejected the proposal to avoid cutting short five current board members’ terms. The county commission can override the veto within 30 days.

Backers of the program for students from low-income backgrounds say it can adapt to Indiana’s new emphasis on career and technical education, along with other shifts.