Protesters confront Tennessee education commissioner over claims of critical race theory in curriculum

State Commissioner of Education Penny Schwinn talks to a small group of about a dozen protestors outside near a school.

Education Commissioner Penny Schwinn’s bus tour of summer learning programs across Tennessee was interrupted Wednesday when protesters gathered to criticize a state-approved curriculum they said promotes critical race theory and discusses sexuality. 

The protest, organized by the Sumner County Republican Assembly, singled out Wit & Wisdom, an English language arts curriculum that introduces themes that some parents say aren’t appropriate for elementary school students. 

About 40 people, many carrying protest signs, confronted Schwinn outside of Benny Bills Elementary School in Gallatin, the third stop on that day’s four-stop tour of rural and suburban schools outside of Nashville.

The commissioner paused for about five minutes to speak with the Sumner County group before reboarding her bus bound for an elementary school in nearby Wilson County.

The protest was the first Schwinn encountered during her whirlwind road trip of 50 districts in 10 days. The tour, which wraps up on Thursday, has spotlighted summer programs that districts must offer to bolster learning disrupted by the pandemic.

The discussion was civil as Schwinn stopped to listen to the crowd’s concerns about Wit & Wisdom.

“It’s failing in Louisiana; we don’t need it here in Tennessee,” Joanna Daniels, a Sumner County mom and board member with the Republican group, told the commissioner.

Schwinn didn’t answer when Daniels asked what she thinks about Wit & Wisdom but noted that curriculum is chosen locally. She encouraged parents to stay informed and praised them for advocating for their children.

“As a parent, I read every book that is coming in front of my kids,” she told the group.

The protest brought together parents and grandparents in rural and suburban Sumner County. Organizers promoted the gathering on social media and via email through notices that mentioned critical race theory and invited people to “protest the indoctrination of our kids.” 

Critical race theory is an academic framework that examines how policies and the law perpetuate systemic racism. A new Tennessee law — spurred in part by the nation’s reckoning with racism and new attention to critical race theory — will limit what teachers can discuss about racism and bias when the new academic year begins.

Great Minds, a Washington D.C.-based publisher, created Wit & Wisdom, which at least 34 Tennessee districts have sought state waivers to use for their younger grades. 

A national conservative group called Moms for Liberty has attacked the curriculum for months in Williamson County, south of Nashville. Critics there argue it introduces subject matter before some children are ready for it, while proponents say the materials challenge students to read and analyze at a rigorous level.

Schwinn discussed the curriculum concerns later Wednesday during a previously scheduled meeting with members of the Moms for Liberty chapter from Williamson County. Also present was Rep. Scott Cepicky, a Republican from Maury County, who pushed for Tennessee’s so-called critical race theory law.

“We recognize this is a conversation many communities are having and it’s important for parents to engage in these conversations,” said Victoria Robinson, communications director for the state education department.

The Sumner County school system piloted Wit & Wisdom to third graders in 2018 and has been adding grade levels. The curriculum was taught in kindergarten through eighth grade during the most recent academic year.

Sumner County Schools Director Del Phillips did not immediately respond when his office was contacted Wednesday for comment.

Editor’s note: This story has been updated with details provided by the state education department about Education Commissioner Penny Schwinn’s meeting Wednesday with Williamson County parents.

The Latest

Researchers think there is potential for artificial intelligence to aid in identifying students who might have previously gone unrecognized.

The Illinois Workforce and Education Research Collaborative’s recent report found that 14% of students took at least one dual credit course in the 2021-22 school year.

In his first two years, New York City schools Chancellor David Banks has made literacy his focal point. Will budget cuts threaten his progress?

Katy Anthes will lead a book study and offer private and small group coaching to help school district leaders and others tamp down heated rhetoric.

Board President and Vice President Reginald Streater and Mallory Fix-Lopez will remain in their roles for the time being. Mayor-elect Cherelle Parker could pick new board members.

Denver Public Schools is spending federal COVID money on a curriculum of mental health activities to help reduce students’ anxiety.