IPS election results could extend conflicts with charters but change balance of power elsewhere

Students on the first day of school in Indianapolis. Voters this year are choosing Indianapolis school board candidates. (Lee Klafczynski for Chalkbeat)

Did you know search engines like Google are changing the way you see news? Keep Chalkbeat’s valuable education coverage at the top of your feeds by clicking here and checking the box next to our name.

Indianapolis Public Schools board incumbents won four of five races in Tuesday’s election, unofficial results showed, which could prolong conflicts with charter schools but change the district’s relationship with state lawmakers and a new entity exerting some control over city schools.

District 3 was the exception — incumbent Hope Duke Star trailed two other candidates, including Daqavise Winston, who led with 34% of the vote as of Wednesday afternoon.

The winners will take office as responsibility for IPS buildings and transportation shifts to the Indianapolis Public Education Corporation, a body created by lawmakers this year to share resources between the district and charter schools. Both groups are celebrating voters’ support for a tax measure for schools at the polls on Election Day.

How the board members approach a working relationship with IPEC, as well as the city’s robust charter school sector, could influence how this process unfolds. Already, the charter school sector has complained about the district’s decisions to step back from a unified enrollment system and reevaluate its contracts with Innovation Network charter schools, which IPS does not directly control.

The current school board did not act to reverse these decisions, despite calls from charter school advocates to do so. The victory by four out of the five incumbents means those calls could continue to cause conflict between the IPS and the charter community. Some charter officials have said IPS lacks the authority to dump the Enroll Indy platform, given the power IPEC has over enrollment under state law.

At the same time, charter leaders can take heart from incumbent Chris Bultman’s victory over Lindsey Cornett in District 4. Bultman works for a nonprofit charter management agency and was endorsed by groups that have supported charters, although he’s stressed that he keeps his work for IPS and the agency separate.

Duke Star’s loss in District 3 also creates uncertainty about the official relationship between IPEC and the school board, because she has served as the district’s representative at the corporation. The new board won’t take over until January.

Before the election, she spoke about the importance of IPEC’s role and the need for the district to address its problems with urgency, while also defending the district’s prerogatives.

The winner in the District 3 race, Daqavise Winston, was endorsed by the Indianapolis Education Association — the local teachers union — as well as other groups that support district-run schools. He told Chalkbeat during the campaign that “IPEC should work with the school board, not around it.” But he also said IPEC represented “an opportunity for great collaboration” across public schools.

Winston also said he wants IPS to work with state lawmakers to address funding gaps for special education in particular, a priority he shares with Bultman.

A total of 15 candidates ran for the five seats.

Speaking at a polling site Tuesday, IPEC Executive Director Karega Rausch said IPEC would be a collaborative partner to the IPS board.

“We look forward to working with folks who are reelected, who are elected, in that collaborative spirit around making sure young people get what they need,” he said.

Unofficial results also showed that Indy voters approved a $95 million referendum that will provide critical funding for IPS and participating charter schools. But even though the measure passed, IPS expects to make around $20 million in cuts.

Chalkbeat’s guide to the school board candidates is available here, and a recap of a forum featuring the candidates is here.

Aleksandra Appleton covers Indiana education policy and writes about K-12 schools across the state. Contact her at aappleton@chalkbeat.org.

The Latest

The Trump administration’s revival of American shipbuilding means thousands more jobs in Philadelphia — and a scramble to train young people for them.

In its first meeting in five months, the nine-member MSCS oversight board said the district needs strong leadership and teacher retention to see “dramatic gains” in achievement.

The school closure plan would merge campuses, shift programs, and affect families navigating the enrollment window.

Register to join our virtual event on Dec. 8 to hear Hanford make the case for a new approach to teaching.

Merci Ames’s youthful ambivalence about school has shaped how she approaches her work as a high school science teacher.

The nationwide blue wave has changed the political makeup of the Indiana General Assembly.