Appeal dismissed in wrongful death lawsuit related to fatal shooting outside of Denver’s East High

An aerial view of a high school football field with the Denver skyline in the background.
Luis Garcia, a 16-year-old student and varsity soccer player, was shot and killed in 2023 while sitting in his car outside East High School in Denver. (Melanie Asmar / Chalkbeat)

Sign up for Chalkbeat Colorado’s free daily newsletter to get the latest reporting from us, plus curated news from other Colorado outlets, delivered to your inbox.

The family of a 16-year-old student who was shot and killed outside Denver’s East High School in 2023 has dropped a wrongful death lawsuit against Denver Public Schools.

The Colorado Court of Appeals dismissed the lawsuit Friday, a court order shows. DPS and the student’s family agreed to the dismissal, according to court documents. The documents do not give a reason. Each side will pay its own legal fees, the documents say.

An attorney for the family said he could not comment Friday. Denver Public Schools said in a statement that the district remains saddened by the death of the student, Luis Garcia.

“We respect the judicial process and the court’s decision to dismiss the appeal, marking the conclusion of this legal matter,” the school district’s statement said.

No one has been charged in connection with Luis’ death. The Denver Police Department said Friday that there are no updates in the case.

In their lawsuit, Luis’ family alleged that a juvenile male, identified only by a pseudonym, shot and killed Luis. The lawsuit alleged the juvenile male stole a white Kia Sportage, ran a red light near East High, drove the Kia “on a direct path straight to Luis,” and opened fire.

Luis was a junior at East and a talented player on the varsity soccer team when he was shot in February 2023 after dropping his cousin off at the school. Luis died of his injuries about two weeks later. His family sued DPS, East High, and the Denver school board in 2024.

They alleged that DPS “subverted and weakened” the security at East after the school board removed armed police officers from DPS schools in 2020, which the family said allowed “potential shooters to believe they would be able to execute an attack.”

Under a state law known as the Claire Davis School Safety Act, districts can be held liable for acts of violence at school if they fail to exercise “reasonable care” to protect students and staff.

But in 2025, a Denver District Court judge ruled that DPS was not liable for Luis’ death because his car was parked on a public street when he was shot.

Luis’ car was parked “where City Park Esplanade intersects East 17th Avenue, where both roads are used for the purpose of public transportation,” Judge Kandace C. Gerdes wrote. “The Court is not persuaded that these roads are ‘within the school facilities’ of East’s Property.”

Luis’ family appealed the ruling but has now agreed to dismiss that appeal.

DPS returned school resource officers to its schools in 2023 after Luis’ death and a separate shooting inside East High a month later. Two former East deans who were injured in that shooting are suing DPS as well. Those lawsuits are ongoing.

Melanie Asmar is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Colorado. Contact Melanie at masmar@chalkbeat.org.

The Latest

As part of the blue wave that swept across the nation on Nov. 3, Democrats in Michigan took control of the House. That gives the party a trifecta beginning in 2027.

Strict bans that rely on Yondr pouches could improve test scores as much as an extra week or two of learning. The study adds to a limited and mixed evidence base for school cell phone bans.

Caron Blanke, Verónica Figoli Fleischer, and P. Barclay Jones are in the running for a seat on the board. Nine other applicants didn’t make the cut.

The review by federal civil rights officials marks the third time in recent years the district has been investigated for alleged antisemitism.

Officials will discuss ‘school consolidation’ following its agenda review session, although it’s unclear which schools officials will discuss.

As New York City’s K-12 student population fell nearly 3% this fall, Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration faces politically fraught decisions over whether to keep propping up under-enrolled school budgets or pursue closures.